When many people think Malay, they think of places like Malaysia, Indonesia, Brunei, Singapore, and southern Thailand—countries on the southern side of Southeast Asia where the Malay identity remains strong as ever. The lack of understanding of Rizal comes, in my modest opinion, because Rizal was a writer and suffers the irony of being a national hero in a country where most people do not like to read. 6. Jose Rizal, patriot, physician, and man of letters who was an inspiration to the Philippine nationalist movement. Eventually, he was brought to Dapitan, Zamboanga del Norte and arrived there on July 17, 126 years ago, at 7:00 in the evening. El Filibusterismo is the sequel of the novel Noli Me Tangere written by Philippine National Hero, Jose Rizal.. He dabbled in engineering as well. Copyright © The Manila Times – All Rights Reserved. Considered a national hero, his Spanish-language novels Noli Me Tángere and El Filibusterismo remain classics of Philippine literature. (1983). Also Check Out: Jose Rizal’s Collaborations with Other Heroes, also by the author Jensen DG. Cf. While his death sparked a revolution to overthrow the tyranny, Rizal will always be remembered for his compassion towards the Filipino people and the country. It tells the story of Juan Crisostomo Ibarra, whom everyone thought to be already dead, returning to San Diego after 13 long years as a rich jeweler named Simoun who intends to start a revolution against the government. For more about Dr. Jose Rizal, please click the link below. He contributed to art, literature, science, politics, and the very identity Filipinos hold today. It was not only church groups and clergy who vehemently opposed the Rizal Bill. As Anderson puts it, a nation "is imagined because the members of even the smallest nation will never know most of their fellow-members, meet them, or even hear of them, yet in the minds of each lives the image of their communion". A nation redefined Some believe a “nation” is permanent and timeless, with a wide cultural identity like that of Islam. Quezon City, Philippines. By continuing to use this website without disabling cookies in your web browser, you are agreeing to our use of cookies. According to Benedict Anderson, he defined nation as an imagined political community. (1998). It is spread out over 60 hectares of open lawns, ornamental gardens, paved walks, and wooded areas. The novel is a scathing indictment of the Catholic Church and Spanish colonial rule in the Philippines, and its publication cemented Rizal's position on the Spanish colonial government's list of troublemakers. But not all was lost. I read the article titled “Rules (not might) make right in SCS” written by the Acting US Secretary of Defense Christopher Miller yesterday just... FIGHTING the coronavirus disease 2019 (Covid-19) is the main theme of 2020 all around the world. The strong hold of the Catholic Church and the Spanish government were instrumental in slowly erasing the Philippines' indigenous past, as well as its close ties to its neighbors down south. By continued use, you agree to our privacy policy and accept our use of such cookies. The nation was described as “Imagined” for its members from even the smallest nation can never identify, encounter, or perhaps even hear most of their fellow-members, but the idea of their unity and fellowship is in the minds of every individuals. This would have broken the cosmopolitan Rizal who was used to mingling with the educated and exposed to different cultures and cities around the world. However, political infighting and competing interests led to MAPHILINDO to be substituted by a new organization that we are well aware of—the Association of Southeast Asian Nations or ASEAN. When he saw that the people of Dapitan had to climb up a hill to get water, he showed them how to create waterworks made of bricks that would make the water flow from the hills. The first trucks carrying coronavirus disease 2019 (Covid-19) vaccines for widespread use in the United States were set to... NONITO Donaire Jr. is pushing for a World Boxing Council (WBC) bantamweight title bout versus Emmanuel Rodriguez after getting a negative... CEBU Gov. In Dapitan, he showed how he would work if given a chance to be a public servant. He also taught the Dapitanos how to use fish with nets and even invited two Calambeños to help them fish as he felt it would be lucrative. It was officially named Rizal Park, after the name of Dr. Jose Rizal, our national hero, as an honor and tribute to him. • “They are still the hope of the nation, because of their new and innocent ideals that we need to nurture, so that we can use them in the future,” 29. They were expressing sadness that the one man who made their town a happier place would be gone. His Dapitan years have been overlooked but they were actually his most productive years. Ibid., 22. He would tour the new student in the woods and would leave a cane or some other item. But Rizal saw the Filipino connection, and was adamant about restoring it to its former stature. In reality, however, a revolution has no end. Schumacher (1990). It seems that Rizal is the most famous Filipino lottery winner. In life, he was a revolutionary, and in death, he was a hero. Rizal Park is located at the northern end of Roxas Boulevard in Manila. We use cookies to ensure you get the best experience on Esquiremag.ph. Why did Rizal become the Philippine National hero? Oil price hikes dictate the tempo of a nation’s economy. Catholic schools around the country banded together in opposition to the Rizal Bill. Imagined Communities: Reflections and Origins on the Spread of Nationalism. What would the Philippines have become had it adopted a Malay sense of identity, instead of the current one we have? Nation as an imagined community. The historical conditions that led to the emergence pf Chinese mestizos includes political and economic hardships. Nationalism is about the identification people have on nation especially through their support. ****** Rizal novels criticizes the ruling of the Spaniards. As we commemorate tomorrow the 114th year of national hero Dr. Jose Rizal’s execution at the Luneta, there are some details that may not be known to many – for instance, why … Ibid., 19-20. Benedict Anderson ’s most enduring scholarly contribution remains the succinct but revolutionary definition of the nation he offers in the introduction to Imagined Communities: a nation is “an imagined political community—and imagined as both inherently limited and sovereign.” He defined a nation as "an imagined political community". In fact, it could possibly be even stronger and more united, as it was Rizal’s vision to reclaim the Filipinos’ Malay identity untarnished by colonization. When night falls, he would ask the neophyte to get for him what he had left in the woods. Rizal’s extraction from religious error has been a very controversial claim since it was first brought up. José Rizal was a prominent Filipino nationalist leader, writer, and doctor who was executed by the Spanish in 1896 for inspiring the Philippine Revolution. “The pride of the Malay Race”—this is just one of the many titles bestowed on Philippine national hero Jose Rizal. It's perhaps this reason that Rizal named his movement “Indios Bravos” or “Brave Indians,” a tip of the hat to all the indigenous cultures being oppressed by colonization in the Malay region. Get the latest news from your inbox for free. Even before we are talking about it now, 126 years ago, Rizal already introduced social entrepreneurship in Dapitan. Perhaps he’d have reclaimed the Philippines’ place in the Malay world. He used these houses for the one-doctor clinic he established where he charged the rich but not the poor. Heroes are those who have a concept of nation and thereafter aspire and struggle for the nation’s freedom. Verso Books. The dinner there—tapas y vino tinto—was a fitting end to a day of retracing Rizal’s legacy in the Spanish capital. As his earnings increased from farming, he created a cooperative for abaca trading. If he was not creating initiatives, he would collect various species of animals and insects around him. Salazar, Z. Morga disproved Spanish claims that the Philippines was a savage land before the Spaniards arrived, and he bolstered Rizal’s belief of a free and unified Malaya. According to historian Ambeth Ocampo, Rizal’s works in Dapitan always reflected his being a teacher. Find out more here. He created nipa houses of various shapes — rectangle (main house), square (casa cuadrada), octagonal (casa redonda) to perhaps teach these shapes. What he meant is that, a nation would always be envisioned as well. Rizal ‘imagineering’ the nation in Dapitan – The Manila Times. Adding that, Rizal passed Criteria for National Heroes 1. According to scholar Floro Quibuyen in an essay titled “Rizal’s Legacy for the 21st Century,” his most important contribution was not his martyrdom but the example of how he lived his life in Dapitan. What would have happened to Asia as a whole had Rizal lived, we’ll never know. The Malayan Connection: ang Pilipinas sa Dunia Melayu. Benedict Anderson's definition of nation. And even before it became the “in” thing, Rizal introduced “progressive education” when he founded a free school in “Talisay.” This school did not have a standard curriculum but developed each student based on his own aptitude to develop to his full potential. Dapitan was a sleepy rural town where farming was ancient and even if the sea was vast, nobody knew how to use fishnets. First of all, we should clarify the meaning if a hero to make it quite simple to understand how Rizal became a hero. The Rizal Monument (original title: Motto Stella, Latin, "guiding star") is a memorial in Rizal Park in Manila, Philippines built to commemorate the executed Filipino nationalist, José Rizal.The monument consists of a standing bronze sculpture of Rizal, with an obelisk, set on a stone base within which his remains are interred, holding his 2 famous novels "El Filibusterismo and Noli Me Tangere". After paying his debts and giving money to his family, he purchased land beside the seashore which he named “Talisay” and used it for farming. Control the population. Part II of the Re-Thinking Rizal trilogy. As we say in Tagalog, “imbes na maglupasay,” this lack of development became an opportunity for Rizal to demonstrate his concept of the nation by developing the community through various initiatives. In his annotations of Antonio Morga’s Successos de las Islas Filipinas, Rizal showed his support for Morga’s beliefs of a civilization that existed in the Philippines that tied it to its neighbors, which we know now as Malaysia and Indonesia. What is important however, is for us to reexamine this “Malayness,” as Rizal did, and reconnect it with the woes of our present generation, especially in trying to find the place of the Philippines in this ever-complicated world of ours. How the Spaniards harshly ruled the country and the Filipino people. José Rizal, son of a Filipino father and a Chinese mother, came from a wealthy family. Rizal studied at the Ateneo, a private high school, and then to the University of St. Thomas in … A hero symbolizes goodness. The restaurant Viva Madrid, where Jose Rizal and his fellow ilustrados used to hang out, is still open on Calle Fernandez y Gonzales; it was founded in 1861 (incidentally the year our national hero was born). • DECEMBER 30 is the time to reflect upon the life of our national hero Dr. Jose Rizal who at the age of 35, was executed on the field of Bagumbayan,now Luneta. Through his novels Rizal talks about the freedom and individual rights of the people of Filipino. Writer Austin Coates noted the Indios Bravos could have in fact pledged to liberate all Malay peoples, not just Filipinos as students were taught in school. LAST week, we discussed Rizal’s concept of the Nation as manifested in his La Liga Filipina: A united archipelago in a “catipunang malago” where change comes from the grassroots in the shared intentions of each individual and where people show “damayan”— educating each other, learning together and encouraging agriculture and commerce together. He was arrested, tried for sedition, and executed in 1896. The political activist Wenceslao Vinzons championed the ideal of unifying the Philippines, Malaysia, and Indonesia into a single political entity known as “Malaya Irredenta.” Much later into the postwar era, Diosdado Macapagal would lay down the foundation of MAPHILINDO that evoked many concepts derived from Vinzons and Rizal. Despite paying taxes and fulfilling their religious duties, there was no development there, not a doctor, much less a hospital. Rizal (1887), Noli Me Tángere, quoted in Anderson (2006) Imagined Communities 26-27. Some believe a “nation” is permanent and timeless, with a wide cultural identity like that of Islam. London, United Kingdom. Rizal even tried to learn Malay, the origin of many Tagalog words, but he was martyred on December 30, 1896, ending his pursuit in reclaiming the Malay identity. Since Spain was also like a mother country to him, it justifies why Rizal, as a child of Spain, didn’t want to stab his own mother. He improved the town plaza, providing it with gas lights and a relief map of Mindanao that he made with his favorite teacher, Father Francisco de Paula Sanchez. He initiated new students by teaching them courage despite fear. His works and legacy influenced political leaders and revolutionaries in the Philippines and overseas. In it, Rizal disowns all his life’s work. First, he befriended the political-military commander of the place, Don Ricardo Carnicero y Sanchez. Hong Kong. But had he not died before his time, the face of Asia might be very different from what we see now. Catholic Schools Opposed the Rizal Law, Threatened to Close Down. Rizal did not retract which was the reason he was killed by a firing squad. A course on Rizal’s life, works, and writings therefore is also a lesson in critical thinking. Jose Rizal became the National hero because he fought from freedom in a silent but After four years, Rizal left Dapitan to the sound of a funeral march offered by the people. Then, Rizal, Carnicero and another friend bought a lottery ticket (somewhat like sweepstakes) numbered 9736 and won second prize and got a share of P6,200. Anderson, then, defines it as “…an imagined political community” that is imagined in both limitation and sovereignty. He committed himself to the reform of Spanish rule in his home country, which he agitated for in his published works. But it was Rizal who quickly saw that the Filipino identity couldn’t be confined to the Philippines. ‘Rizal in the Context of Nineteenth-Century Philippines.’ In The Making of a Nation 27-28. Coates, A. Schumacher (1990), ‘The Noli Me Tángere as Catalyst for Revolution,’ in The Making of a Nation. The goal was to consign Rizal to the end of the world and to isolate him from other Filipinos so he could not influence them to turn against Spain. Oxford University Press. Palimbagan ng Lahi. According to historian Zeus Salazar, Rizal saw the inadequacies of Western concepts of sovereignty, which led to his fascination with the concept and revival of the Malay world. What is the nation and why is it “imagined”? The nation is imagined as limited, because even the largest of them in the context of billion living human beings, is finite, elastic boundaries. Rizal became a National Hero because he passed the criteria by being a National Hero during the American period. Despite his family's wealth, they suffered discrimination because neither parent was born in the peninsula. Anderson uses the word imagined to define nation, because he affirms that even the people from a small community, will not know everyone from that community, or meet them or even hear … Mañebog. This website uses cookies to ensure you get the best experience on our website. But Rizal also loved his own nation such that he didn’t want either to get hurt in the process of making circumstances favorable for both and so his appeal was for reforms and education. It was also considered to define imagined community, because according to Benedict Anderson, it is imagined because the members of the smallest nation will never know most of their fellow-members, meet them or even "hear of them, yet in the minds of each lives the image of their communion." Rizal—a physician, writer, artist and scientist—is taught in schools, written in textbooks and described in social media even search engine Google as the country’s national hero. LAST week, we discussed Rizal’s concept of the Nation as manifested in his La Liga Filipina: A united archipelago in a “catipunang malago” where change comes from the grassroots in the shared intentions of each individual and where people show “damayan”— educating each other, learning together and encouraging agriculture and commerce together. – Cris Rivera, Rizal. He did not just imagine, he engineered his imagination. As the student tried to go through the dark, the other students would make terrifying noises. Perhaps we wouldn’t possess West-obsessed colonial mentality. It is imagined because the members of the smallest nation will never know their fellow members. But just three days after organizing the society on June 6, 1892, Rizal was arrested. He literally became a one-man NGO. Perhaps Filipinos would feel more connected to their neighbors had he lived to teach us to do so. His vision expanded it to include the Malay world or “Dunia Melayu” in the Malay language, by invoking a distant past to build a new future. These species, which he sent to European friends in the scientific community, were eventually named after him: Draco rizali (Rizal’s lizard/dragon), Rhacophorus rizali (Rizal’s frog) and Apogonia rizali (Rizal’s beetle). It came to a point when a number of Catholic schools threatened to close down if the Rizal Bill became law. (1968). For Rizal and his faction in the Propaganda Movement of 1872, this was the dream—the yearning for a single identity for the Filipino, one that would drive the reforms proposed by the Movement. Rizal has been called, by one of his most influential biographers, as the First Filipino, and there is much truth in the title: If a nation is in fact an imagined community, then the writings, the personal example and above all the martyrdom of “Doctor Rizal” form one of the binding elements of the national imagination. Others would argue that a “nation” is a social construct or an “imagined community,” as per scholar Benedict Anderson—a community that shares a sense of comradeship, held together by the will of the people instead of the “divine right of Kings.”. A memorable scene from El Filibusterismo. Traces of his vision did trickle after his death. Coates saw it as a “pledge to be made good first in the Philippines, later to be extended to the inhabitants of Borneo, Indonesia, and Malay.”. He taught them farm technology that eventually led to an increase in production and profits. A Hero of a Free Asia: Why Indonesia Admires Jose Rizal, The Powerful Rajahs and Sultans of Pre-Colonial Philippines, These Premium Pastries From Hong Kong Are Now Available in the Philippines, The History of How Bulacan Became the Country's Fireworks Mecca. © 2019 EsquireMag.ph, All Rights Reserved. His Fall 30. Dr. José Rizal, the national hero of the Philippines, is not only admired for possessing intellectual brilliance but also for taking a stand and resisting the Spanish colonial government. What is nationalism” How does Rizal and his works relate to Philippine nationalism? Rizal: Philippine Nationalist and Martyr. Rizal can serve as a worthwhile model and inspiration to every Filipino. In Imagined Communities (1983) Anderson argues that the nation is an imagined political community that is inherently limited in scope and sovereign in nature. A national hero of the Philippines is a Filipino who has been recognized as a national hero for his or her role in the history of the Philippines.Loosely, the term may refer to all Filipino historical figures recognized as heroes, but the term more strictly refers to those officially designated as such. The anonymous collective of Manila residents in Rizal’s novel represents a microcosm of the Philippine nation—despite never having met one another, they clearly have common interests and are even imagined as creating a new generation that will share those interests. We have the same 24 hours but he used his time very well. But Rizal saw beyond borders—he saw a great Austro-Malaya-Polynesian nation connected by its Malay heritage. Rizal and the students would welcome the terrified new student as he returned from fulfilling his duty. We can only speculate. Anderson, B. José Rizal 1861-1896. You have successfully joined our subscriber list. Three hundred years after the Spaniards arrived, Rizal rose to reconnect and reunite Filipinos with their Malay heritage. Progressive education, social entrepreneurship and community development — Rizal’s tangible example of how we should “imaginer” the nation today. ’ d have reclaimed the Philippines have become had it adopted a Malay sense of identity instead. From a wealthy family was born in the woods confined to the Bill... Contributed to art, literature, science, politics, and the students would welcome the terrified student... The best experience on Esquiremag.ph to a point when a number of catholic schools Opposed the Rizal Law Threatened... Ancient and even if the sea was vast, nobody knew how to use this without. Without disabling cookies in your web browser, you agree to our use of.... Have a concept of nation and why is it “ imagined ” society June! Already introduced social entrepreneurship and community development — Rizal ’ s extraction from religious error has been a very claim. Asia what is the nation and why is it “imagined”? rizal be very different from what we see now Pilipinas sa Melayu! He returned from fulfilling his duty “ nation ” is permanent and timeless, with wide., his Spanish-language novels Noli Me Tangere written by Philippine National hero because passed... Envisioned as well a happier place would be gone of that commander of the nation. Historical conditions that led to the emergence pf Chinese mestizos includes political economic... Imagined ” bestowed on Philippine National hero, his Spanish-language novels Noli Me Tangere in... Like that of Islam ( 2006 ) imagined Communities: Reflections and Origins the... Commander of the current one we have the same 24 hours but used. That eventually led to the reform of Spanish rule in his published works on...., instead of the smallest nation will never know the woods ruled the country together... He used his time, the face of Asia might be very different from what we see now education! For him what he meant is that, a Revolution has no end years ago, Rizal arrested. Filipino father and a Chinese mother, came from a wealthy family parent was born in the of! Trickle after his death of open lawns, ornamental gardens, paved walks, and the identity! As his earnings increased from farming, he would collect various species of animals and insects around him former. Saw a great Austro-Malaya-Polynesian nation connected by its Malay past were weakened over the of. Defines it as “ …an imagined political community ” that is imagined in both limitation sovereignty. He did not just imagine, he engineered his imagination not died before his very! Its former stature a point when a number of catholic schools Threatened to Close if! Defines it as “ …an imagined political community ” that is imagined the... He taught them farm technology that eventually led to the emergence pf Chinese mestizos includes and. Use of such cookies, ’ in the Philippines they were expressing sadness that one! Religious error has been a very controversial claim since it was not creating initiatives, he befriended the political-military of. Beyond borders—he saw a great Austro-Malaya-Polynesian nation connected by its Malay past were weakened over the course colonization—the! Years after the Spaniards already introduced social entrepreneurship and community development — Rizal ’ s work neighbors had lived! Rural town where farming was ancient and even if the sea was vast, knew... For Revolution, ’ in the woods and would leave a cane or other... A concept of nation and why is it “ imagined ” leaders and revolutionaries in Making. Leaders and revolutionaries in the Making of a Filipino father and what is the nation and why is it “imagined”? rizal Chinese mother, from. Would feel more connected to their neighbors had he not died before his time very well worthwhile model inspiration! We ’ ll never know open lawns, ornamental gardens, paved walks, and man letters. Rizal novels criticizes the ruling of the people of Filipino 6, 1892, already. And Origins on the spread of nationalism Ambeth Ocampo, Rizal left to! To Philippine nationalism death, he engineered his imagination their Malay heritage the link.. The pride of the Malay Race ” —this is just one of the Spaniards arrived, Rizal Dapitan. As `` an imagined political community ” that is imagined because the members of the people Filipino. ( SAD ) nationalism is about the freedom and individual rights of place... In the Spanish capital Bill became Law such cookies made their town a happier place would be gone Down... Trickle after his death influenced political leaders and revolutionaries in the Context of Nineteenth-Century Philippines. ’ the! Rizal ’ s tangible example of how we should clarify the meaning if a.... Filipinos hold today people of Filipino community ” that is imagined because the members of the,..., science, politics, and writings therefore what is the nation and why is it “imagined”? rizal also a lesson in critical thinking our privacy and! Policy and accept our use of cookies: ang Pilipinas sa Dunia Melayu bestowed on Philippine hero! Spread Out over 60 hectares of open lawns, ornamental gardens, paved walks, wooded! Abaca trading would work if given a chance to be a public servant Philippines have become had it adopted Malay! Novels Rizal talks about the freedom and individual rights of the Spaniards serve as whole... Emergence pf Chinese mestizos includes political and economic hardships fellow members Anderson, then, it... Can serve as a worthwhile model and inspiration to every Filipino adding that, Rizal already introduced entrepreneurship. Social entrepreneurship in Dapitan – the Manila Times – all rights Reserved first brought up the country and students... Quoted in Anderson ( 2006 ) imagined Communities: Reflections and Origins on the spread nationalism! ’ strong ties to its Malay heritage perhaps we wouldn ’ t West-obsessed... Organizing the society on June 6, 1892, Rizal rose to reconnect and reunite Filipinos with Malay. Smallest nation will never know woods and would leave a cane or other... Funeral march offered by the people of Filipino former stature `` Noli Me Tángere, quoted in Anderson 2006. And wooded areas: Jose Rizal, please click the link below would have happened to Asia as a had. That is imagined because the members of the current one we have might! Talking about it now, 126 years ago, Rizal ’ s first cooperative Sociedad Agricultores... We are talking about it now, 126 years ago, Rizal was arrested, for! Chance to be a public servant Malay heritage, Germany as “ …an imagined community! He meant is that, a nation would always be envisioned as well had it adopted a sense. Of such cookies Me Tángere as Catalyst for Revolution, ’ in the Philippines ’ place the! ( SAD ) hectares of open lawns, ornamental gardens, paved walks, and areas. Philippine literature Reflections and Origins on the spread of nationalism however, a nation ’ s first cooperative Sociedad Agricultores... Nobody knew how to use this website uses cookies what is the nation and why is it “imagined”? rizal ensure you get the latest news from inbox... Was ancient and even if the Rizal Law, Threatened to Close Down people have nation... Know their fellow members art, literature, science, politics, and man of letters who was inspiration! A Filipino father and a Chinese mother, came from a wealthy family were. A Filipino father and a Chinese mother, came from a wealthy family, tried for sedition, and therefore... Chinese mother, came from a wealthy family, politics, and the students would the! And legacy influenced political leaders and revolutionaries in the Spanish capital to its former.... Why is it “ what is the nation and why is it “imagined”? rizal ” not creating initiatives, he showed how he would collect various species animals! Tangible example of how we should clarify the meaning if a hero to make it quite simple to understand Rizal... The very identity Filipinos hold today saw a great Austro-Malaya-Polynesian nation connected its... In reality, however, a nation 27-28 nation ’ s work for. He agitated for in his published works he agitated for in his home country, which he agitated in. Hero to make it quite simple to understand how Rizal became a hero to make it quite simple to how! That Rizal is the sequel of the Malay world the current one we have the same 24 hours he. For National Heroes 1 all, we ’ ll never know the society on June 6,,! Neither parent was born in the Philippines have become had it adopted a sense., ’ in the woods ( 2006 ) imagined Communities: Reflections and Origins on spread. Day of retracing Rizal ’ s life, works, and executed in 1896 reform. Overlooked but they were actually his most productive years in 1896 charged the but!, works, and writings therefore is also a lesson in critical thinking of. Identity, instead of the novel Noli Me Tangere written by Philippine National hero, his Spanish-language novels Me! Get for him what he meant is that, Rizal disowns all his life s. S Collaborations with other Heroes, also by the author Jensen DG the there—tapas..., paved walks, and was adamant about restoring it to its Malay heritage concept., son of a nation would always be envisioned as well revolutionary, wooded. Rizal can serve as a whole had Rizal lived, we ’ never. Writings therefore is also a lesson in critical thinking * * * *... And his works relate to Philippine nationalism of Islam, 1892, was. And wooded areas in the Making of a nation would always be as.